Finding the perfect reusable baby wipes can feel like a quest. With so many options available, ranging from pricey bamboo cloths to inexpensive flannel squares, navigating the choices can be overwhelming. This review aims to simplify your search by providing a detailed comparison of several popular reusable baby wipe brands, helping you make an informed decision based on your budget and cleaning needs. We'll explore factors like softness, absorbency, durability, and overall effectiveness to determine which wipes truly stand out.This comprehensive review covers a range of options, from the budget-friendly Buttons wipes to the luxuriously soft Grove Collaborative UNK wipes. We'll delve into the pros and cons of each, including their performance on different types of messes, their longevity after multiple washes, and their overall value for money. Whether you prioritize softness, size, or affordability, this review will help you find the best reusable baby wipes to suit your little one and your lifestyle.
Pros And Cons
- Affordable (about a dollar apiece)
- Soft
- Stay soft
- Don't stain easily
- Can be used as a booster in newborn cloth diapers
- Very soft
- Large size (almost as large as Grove wipes)
- Don't grip well for poopy messes
- Large size
- Usually only one wipe needed per use, even for bad messes
- Made of bamboo
- Very soft
- More expensive
- Very soft
- Grip well
- Good price
Read more: 12 Pack Baby Washcloths: 5 Adorable Designs
Rovia Cloth Wipes: A Reliable Choice
I started with the Rovia wipes, a personal favorite. Sixteen out of the original set were still in use; a few seem to have mysteriously vanished. Despite the missing wipes, their quality makes up for it. They rarely stain, a significant plus for reusable wipes. The price point is also quite reasonable, around a dollar per wipe.
The softness is noteworthy; they retain their softness after many washes. An added bonus is their suitability as diaper boosters for newborns, further enhancing their versatility.
Grove Collaborative UNK Wipes: Large and Effective
Next are the Grove Collaborative UNK wipes, a pack of six generously sized wipes. Their size is significantly larger than other wipes in my collection. This larger size typically means I only need one wipe per cleaning, unless it's an exceptionally messy situation.
Made from bamboo, they are incredibly soft and effective. Even stubborn messes are handled effectively with a single wipe. Despite their higher price, their effectiveness makes them a worthwhile investment.
Buttons Flannel and Velour Wipes: Budget-Friendly Options
The Buttons flannel wipes are an inexpensive, reliable option. The 15-wipe pack is a great value. Though slightly smaller than the Rovia wipes, their softness and quality make them a solid choice. For everyday use, they are quite satisfactory.
Their velour counterparts are equally soft and offer excellent grip, making them highly effective at cleaning. Similar in size to the Rovia wipes, their softness and price make them strong contenders.
Surged Thread Wipes and Gerber Wipes: Mixed Results
The surged thread wipes, a freebie from a past order, are a twelve-pack of various colors. While effective at removing messes, their thinness is akin to disposable wipes. They are quite thin, and some show signs of wear after multiple washes.
The Gerber wipes are a bit of a disappointment. While initially soft, they lose their softness quickly and lack the grip necessary for efficient cleaning. Their thinness and loss of softness detract from their overall usability. They are bigger than other wipes but are not a preferred choice.
Baby Washcloths: Simple and Effective (But Limited)
Lastly, I have three simple baby washcloths. Their extreme softness makes them less effective for cleaning particularly messy situations. While large and absorbent for wet messes, their lack of grip makes them less ideal for dealing with thicker substances.
Their size is comparable to the Grove wipes, but their softness makes them less effective at cleaning thicker messes. They work well for wet cleaning but fall short on tougher jobs.
Conclusion: Finding Your Perfect Wipe
This review explored several cloth wipe options, each with its own strengths and weaknesses. The Rovia and Grove wipes stood out for their softness, effectiveness, and relative affordability. The Buttons wipes provide a budget-friendly alternative with good quality.
Gerber wipes were less impressive due to their loss of softness and poor grip. The washcloths are great for general cleaning, but not ideal for messy situations. Ultimately, the best wipe depends on individual preferences and needs.