This review dives into Dr. Jacobs Naturals Liquid Castile Soap in Coconut, offering a detailed account of its performance and user experience. The author, a long-time user of Dr. Bronner's Castile soap, sought a change and found it in Dr. Jacobs' unique formulation. The review focuses on key aspects like the soap's surprisingly thick consistency, its subtly sweet coconut scent, and its effectiveness as a cleanser for face, body, and hair. Particular attention is paid to a comparison with the author's previous favorite brand, highlighting the superior texture and equally impressive cleaning power of Dr. Jacobs' offering.This in-depth analysis explores the sensory experience of using this Castile soap, emphasizing the pleasant fragrance and luxurious feel. The author details its performance in removing various impurities, including sunscreen and chlorine residue, while also addressing its impact on sensitive skin. Ultimately, the review aims to provide a comprehensive assessment of Dr. Jacobs Naturals Liquid Castile Soap, determining whether it deserves a spot among top-tier Castile soap options and offering a well-informed recommendation to potential consumers.
Pros And Cons
- Thick consistency
- Lightly coconut-scented
- Cleanses face and body without drying
- Removes product buildup and chlorine from hair
- Effectively removes sunblock
- Not yet tested for household cleaning purposes
Read more: 5 Best Baby Bar Soaps with Green Tea
First Impressions and Initial Thoughts
I recently decided to try Dr. Jacobs Naturals Liquid Castile Soap in Coconut, seeking a change from my usual Dr. Bronner's. The packaging immediately caught my eye; it looked sleek and modern. The label promised a thicker consistency than traditional Castile soaps, which piqued my interest.

Upon first use, the thicker texture was indeed noticeable, a welcome change from the runnier consistency of other brands. The scent was subtly coconut, not overpowering which I appreciated. I was curious to see how this would perform compared to my beloved Dr. Bronner's.

Performance as a Face, Body, and Hair Wash
I used the Dr. Jacobs soap on my face, body, and hair. For my face, it provided a thorough cleanse without the drying effect I've experienced with some Castile soaps. It effectively removed sunblock after a day at the pool.

On my body, it left my skin feeling clean and refreshed. And for my hair? It was a revelation! It thoroughly cleansed my hair, removing product buildup and chlorine residue without making my hair feel like straw.

Texture and Scent
One of the most striking features of this soap is its thicker consistency. Unlike the typical watery texture of many Castile soaps, this one is much more substantial, almost like a shampoo. It’s a very pleasant change!

The coconut scent is very light and refreshing; it's not overwhelming or artificial-smelling. I found the subtle fragrance quite enjoyable and not at all irritating to my sensitive skin.
Comparison to Dr. Bronner's and Other Castile Soaps
While I love Dr. Bronner's, this soap stands out with its unique texture and refreshing coconut scent. Dr. Bronner’s is a reliable choice, but the Dr. Jacobs Castile Soap offers a luxuriously thicker formula and pleasant coconut fragrance.

I’ve tried other Castile soaps, but this one from Dr. Jacobs Naturals is a clear favorite. The thicker consistency makes it more enjoyable to use and its cleansing power is exceptional. The light fragrance is a bonus.
Overall Conclusion and Rating
Overall, I'm extremely impressed with Dr. Jacobs Naturals Liquid Castile Soap. Its thicker consistency, subtle coconut scent, and superior cleansing power make it a top contender in my book.

It’s effective as a face, body, and hair wash, leaving my skin and hair feeling clean and healthy without any dryness. I highly recommend giving it a try. For me, it's a new favorite!
